Here’s the four steps to designing a highly complex game that can succeed with a wide market audience:
1. Make the basic actions and objectives at the start of the game extremely simple, so you can jump in with minimal barrier to entry. Path of Exile and Warframe get extraordinarily complex but at first they’re just simple “shoot doods, go boom”. StarCraft starts with workers and a few combat units. Minecraft is fun to play as a basic survival sandbox before you know what enchanting tables are. Even Dwarf Fortress has a simple start with clear objectives.
2. Focus on building Curiosity over Confusion whenever possible during play. Confusion is the evil twil of Curiosity. Curiosity motivated us to cross oceans, and it’s easy to invoke with minimal tutorialization (by definition). Confusion is the disempowering, unnerving feeling of being ‘lost’ with no clear direction. Curiosity is looking to the horizon and wondering what’s beyond. Confusion is being lost at sea and not knowing how you got there, or how to get back.
3. Ensure that the a little knowledge leads to massive, immediate, obvious impact on your performance and success. This is huge. If you spend 1 hour looking up info with no obvious in-game payoff, it’s hard to engage. If you spend 10 minutes looking something up that produces a huge performance improvement, it’s very exciting to keep looking that stuff up.
4. Get players to care about goals that require making use of this forbidden knowledge. Make it so it allows you to do things you can’t do otherwise; unlocking new functionality or accomplishing specific goals. Figuring out how to get a triple jump in a game that normally only allows a double jump, creating a TNT duplicator, etc. Forbidden knowledge that allows a 40% damage increase only truly does this if you are hitting a DPS check you otherwise wouldn’t to phase a boss early or otherwise ignore mechanics. The purpose here is to spike player motivation enough that it’s worth seeking out and Showing Off the knowledge.
If your game is social (co-op activities in particular) you often get this for free if people want to flex for friends. A 40% damage increase might not change much in the fight itself, but it still lets you impress your friends with the parse number. Only if it’s easy to show that off though.